Media Briefing: The pros and cons of three commerce pricing models

On this week’s Media Briefing, media editor Kayleigh Barber breaks down the completely different pricing fashions that commerce publishers use.

The important thing hits:

  • Publishers are testing new pricing fashions of their commerce companies, which allows them to be paid at completely different factors through the shopper shopping for journey. 
  • Flat-fee pricing is being utilized by some publishers as a step beneath branded content material, however some execs fear it should impression their commerce content material’s editorial integrity to incorporate paid product placements. 
  • Price-per-click pricing tends to pay publishers much less, however it offers them the possibility to receives a commission whereas testing traits and new merchandise with their viewers. 

Over the previous few months, some publishers with commerce companies have begun testing new pricing fashions with the hopes of accelerating e-commerce income past the incremental commissions earned from affiliate hyperlinks featured on their websites. 

For these publishers, commerce is beginning to be seen as an avenue for advertisers to achieve their goal clients who’re nearer to the purpose of creating a purchase order. To win that bottom-of-the-funnel enterprise, commerce groups have begun providing cost-per-click and flat-fee charges for manufacturers. 

“I simply bought again from Cannes and what I heard from most CMOs will not be a lot about price range discount, however a shift between higher funnel and decrease funnel spend,” mentioned Josh Stinchcomb, CRO of Dow Jones, which just lately launched its new The Wall Road Journal-adjacent commerce model Purchase Facet earlier this month. 

Price-per-acquisition (CPA) has been the standard pricing construction for publishers with affiliate companies, given how a lot of a “set it and overlook it” enterprise mannequin it’s. And whereas it’s nonetheless the lion’s share of how affiliate income is earned for a lot of publishers, the passive nature of it additionally limits negotiations and leaves media firms on the mercy of manufacturers who function by means of affiliate networks like Skimlinks. 

Not all publishers are offered on these new pricing fashions, nonetheless. Some worry that they might impression editorial integrity or just aren’t well worth the problem. However of the publishers I spoke with, entertaining direct offers with retailers and retailers has change into a no brainer technique to enhance fee charges and total commerce income. 

“The intention is to not have any form of branded content material or pay-to-play content material. That’s not a part of our technique in any respect. However I do suppose there are going to be extra alternatives over time to do extra direct affiliate offers with manufacturers,” mentioned Stinchcomb.

Listed below are three completely different pricing fashions being utilized in publishers’ commerce companies and execs and cons as to why publishers are or are usually not incorporating them into their methods. — Kayleigh Barber


What it’s: 

Flat-fee partnerships are direct offers closed with a retailer or service provider in alternate for assured placement of the model’s services or products inside the writer’s content material. The retailer pays the writer a set sum of money upfront, whether or not or not the writer finally ends up driving gross sales. Usually, the writer doesn’t make any particular ensures, similar to minimal variety of impressions and even which merchandise will likely be featured. The offers can change into extra nuanced past this, given the pliability and customization that direct offers permit for, however for the publishers that apply this mannequin, like Vice Media Group, sure boundaries are put in place, similar to not permitting the model to see the content material earlier than publication, to guarantee that editorial integrity is maintained. 


  • Just like an promoting deal, the writer earns 1000’s of {dollars} by means of a flat payment partnership at one time, versus ready for commissions to trickle in by means of affiliate hyperlinks. 
  • Like a branded content material deal, flat payment offers can embody a wide range of methods wherein the model’s merchandise are included inside content material, together with podcasts, newsletters and reside purchasing. This gives a level of testing and studying to see which platforms and content material merchandise are essentially the most impactful for that model in changing audiences, with out risking the possibility of the writer not incomes any cash from together with the product. 
  • Tips will be set within the contract to restrict how a lot oversight a model will get with the content material, not like branded content material partnerships the place an advertiser usually receives ultimate say earlier than publication. 


  • If a model or a product proves to be actually in style with the writer’s viewers, there runs the chance that the writer won’t earn as a lot cash from the gross sales it drove as it might if it used a standard CPA mannequin. 
  • Some publishers really feel that paid placements or inclusions of merchandise in articles threaten editorial integrity. 
  • Flat-fee modeling can compete with the promoting facet of the home, and if not cautious, manufacturers can pay a fraction of the value for what could possibly be thought of comparable campaigns internally. 

Writer instance:

Vice Media Group is one media firm that’s not solely testing flat payment pricing, however hoping to see it develop as an possibility that manufacturers select, in accordance with chief digital officer Cory Haik, who added that the amount of offers executed on this class have elevated by 1,000% from Q1 2021 to Q1 2022. Haik wouldn’t disclose the overall variety of flat payment offers.

On the firm, flat-fee partnerships cap out at $50,000, in accordance with Samantha Baker, vp of commerce and partnerships, who spoke about this mannequin throughout Digiday Media’s Commerce Week occasion that came about final month. She mentioned through the occasion that any manufacturers trying to exceed that worth level will get despatched over to the promoting group to work with them on a branded content material deal as an alternative. 

Flat-fee offers are sometimes reserved for manufacturers that contemplate VMG to be a prime driver of gross sales, Baker mentioned, similar to Our Place or Nordstrom, who’re prone to ask for a flat-fee deal.

A deal of this nature can embody something from a devoted e-newsletter inclusion to a minimal variety of mentions in commerce story round-ups to a set variety of devoted articles on merchandise from that model in a given month – or a mixture of these. These offers, nonetheless, by no means assure which merchandise will likely be chosen, or if the opinions will likely be optimistic, and the model doesn’t get to see the content material forward of time, Baker added. 


What it’s: 

Price-per-click (CPC) pricing offers publishers a referral payment when a reader clicks by means of to a model’s web site or product web page. In contrast to an affiliate hyperlink that makes use of a cost-per-acquisition mannequin, the writer doesn’t earn a share of any gross sales made by means of that hyperlink, however are awarded a comparably smaller price for getting a shopper into the model’s ecosystem. 


  • This opens a door to working with retailers and retailers who’ve smaller advertising budgets and couldn’t in any other case afford the fee charges of a CPA mannequin or the value of working inside an affiliate community. 
  • CPC pricing can be utilized in each direct offers with manufacturers and as a pricing possibility by means of affiliate networks. 
  • That is additionally a manner for publishers to write down about new manufacturers or merchandise and doubtlessly earn cash whereas studying whether or not or not these issues resonate with their audiences. For instance, if a writer is writing about nutritional vitamins for the primary time, it should earn a small referral payment from the vitamin retailer when a reader clicks the hyperlink to study extra concerning the vitamin, versus solely earning profits after the client purchases the product. If the nutritional vitamins are usually not interesting sufficient to the publication’s readers to get them to purchase, the publication will nonetheless earn some cash from clicks to study extra concerning the product.


  • The value level of what a writer can earn is way decrease than a CPA mannequin. On common, a writer can earn between $3,000 to $5,000 monthly from a CPC deal. 
  • Some publishers don’t suppose the income earned from this mannequin is well worth the effort of organising the deal within the first place, notably if this pricing mannequin is completed by means of a direct deal. 
  • Not with the ability to see conversion charges could make it laborious for publishers and types to know the way profitable they had been in driving gross sales of the product or how effectively the publication’s viewers appreciated or disliked the product/model. 
  • Manufacturers who can not afford to function in an affiliate community may not have the stamina or bandwidth to deal with site visitors or gross sales that are available by means of publications with giant audiences, in accordance with Wirecutter’s govt director of commerce Leilani Han. 

Recommendation from a advisor: 

If a model chooses to go this route, they need to make sure that they’re taking advantage of having the brand new reader of their ecosystem, in accordance with Ben Zettler, a digital advertising and e-commerce advisor. 

To do that, when a consumer is available in by means of the precise hyperlink, set a pop-up provide that entices them to enroll in a e-newsletter in alternate for a reduction, like 10% off your first buy. “Then you may see actually rapidly, like inside the first week [or] first couple of days, if individuals are changing,” mentioned Zettler. 


What it’s: 

Price-per-acquisition (CPA) pricing is essentially the most conventional pricing mannequin for publishers’ affiliate companies as a result of they usually are coordinated by means of giant affiliate networks, although they will also be utilized in direct offers with manufacturers. A writer earns a fee from the direct gross sales it drives by means of the protection of a services or products. Fee charges can differ drastically primarily based on product class, worth level and model price range. 


  • Publishers are inclined to earn extra income from fee charges versus from CPC referral charges. 
  • Determining what merchandise audiences like and are keen to pay for is very easy as a result of the publishers can see precisely what their readers are shopping for due to the conversion measurement. 
  • Some hyperlinks permit publishers to earn a share of the client’s complete cart gross sales, past the precise product it covers, doubtlessly rising the quantity of fee income earned


  • Income will not be assured.
  • There are lots of alternatives to lose attribution from the writer to the purpose of buy. If a reader doesn’t full a purchase order, or waits till later to purchase the product by going to the positioning straight, the writer loses out on the fee price.

What we’ve heard

“I don’t actually go on the Reels. I really feel like my mother does that.”

Cadence, a 16-year-old who was amongst the Gen Z attendees that Digiday interviewed throughout VidCon

3 questions with The nineteenth’s Julia B. Chan

The identical day the Supreme Court docket introduced it might overturn Roe v. Wade, Julia B. Chan, editor in chief of The nineteenth, tweeted that the non-profit information publication — which covers the intersection of gender, politics and coverage — was “made for this second.”

The identify for The nineteenth comes from the nineteenth Modification, which granted ladies the suitable to vote. The location’s brand accommodates an asterisk as a reminder that the modification utilized solely to white ladies.

“The entire information that has been popping out in The nineteenth’s lifespan within the final three years has proven precisely why a newsroom that facilities ladies and LGBTQ+ communities and ladies of shade is so, so vital,” Chan mentioned.

Digiday spoke to Chan to learn the way The nineteenth ready for the Supreme Court docket ruling and its plans for future protection, the report site visitors the positioning obtained final week and her ideas on social media insurance policies discouraging journalists to take a stance on the ruling. — Sara Guaglione

This dialog has been edited and condensed.

How has The nineteenth ready for the information of the SCOTUS ruling, and the way do you intend to maneuver protection ahead?

We’ve had a few dozen items printed since Friday. [Breaking news reporter Jennifer Gerson and economic reporter Chabeli Carrazana] spent all day making calls on Friday to cowl clinics, in an effort to report out and get these items out into the world that had been primarily snapshots of the second Roe fell. We wished to ensure we had a really human-centered method threaded all through our protection. We had been capable of publish our breaking information piece three minutes after the information broke from SCOTUS, as a result of we had been prepared. We’ve been planning for this for – if not this complete previous 12 months, for the final three years, fairly actually. We had been prepared at each [SCOTUS] determination day to principally mobilize as quickly because the information got here down. Our abortion tracker – which is basically a state by state tracker – was printed earlier than Dobbs [v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the case through which the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade]. We knew it was one thing we might use as a instrument for our audiences to maintain them updated on breaking information and the way that information impacts every state.

A few 12 months in, The nineteenth expanded its mission from desirous to middle and serve ladies to actually recognizing we don’t wish to simply speak to and serve ladies, however we wish to be participating and serving any marginalized gender. That’s how our protection has expanded round LGBTQ+ communities – a section of communities that has not been served traditionally by legacy media. With that in thoughts, we’re taking a look at what the impression on LGBTQ+ communities in mild of Dobbs will likely be. It is a main matter for us as a information group.

Did you see an uptick in site visitors after the ruling? 

It was one of many highest readership weeks of our historical past. We noticed thrice the typical engagement throughout social media platforms. It was double our common weekly e-newsletter subscriber progress. We additionally noticed new commitments to our donations from our members, which is a big signal of assist. They noticed what was occurring and so they felt galvanized to take motion. And a type of actions was to both donate or to re-up their donation to the nineteenth.

I’m positive you’ve seen the chatter concerning the memos newsrooms obtained, reminding them of their organizations’ social media insurance policies and to not take a public stance on the SCOTUS ruling. Do you agree with these insurance policies?

It’s a welcome dialog. We noticed a variety of these pointers come from legacy organizations. I feel a few of these pointers are couched within the fable of objectivity – that journalists want to look or be perceived as goal to report. However we all know that’s not the case as a result of journalists are people. And that must be what informs and conjures up our pointers and our insurance policies. Once I take into consideration objectivity, it’s not perceived objectivity of a person, which we will’t management. I can’t management what you consider me, proper? Nevertheless it’s concerning the objectivity in our processes. How are we creating the journalism? 

I feel these pointers are usually not black and white, and I do suppose among the preliminary concepts that they’re sourced from should be interrogated, and I’m within the enterprise of interrogating that. At The nineteenth, we actually do encourage our journalists and our total workers to convey their lived experiences to the work and to the office. As a company, we consider bringing your full lived expertise to the journalism is a profit to the journalism, not a detriment. It’s what makes our journalism particular. It makes our journalism stand out and is differentiated from different shops.

Numbers to know

$3.99: Month-to-month worth for Snapchat’s new subscription tier that’s imaginatively titled Snapchat+.

1 million: Variety of electronic mail subscribers that Axios Native has amassed in complete.

-12%: Proportion decline in print gross sales for the highest 25 U.S. newspapers from March 2021 to March 2022.

>360: Variety of newspapers which have shut down since late 2019.

How TikTok took over VidCon in 2022

After a two 12 months hiatus, VidCon returned to Anaheim, California, in late June, and the 2022 version was a mixture of Comedian-Con for creators and their followers, a reunion for the digital video business and a debutante ball for the creators — and one creator platform specifically — that stole the highlight through the pandemic.

However there was one huge distinction. What was as soon as an occasion dominated by YouTube has now been taken over by TikTok.

Throughout VidCon, Digiday spoke with varied creators from TikTok, YouTube and Instagram in addition to business executives about what this 12 months’s model of the annual occasion indicated concerning the state of the digital video business and creator financial system. Watch the video above.

What we’ve lined

Vice Media Group brings again program for small, Black-owned companies:

  • Known as Black+, this system’s second iteration will characteristic 5 enterprise, down from 12 final 12 months.
  • VMG mentioned the smaller choice is supposed to permit the media firm to supply extra high quality assist to every enterprise.

Learn extra about VMG’s Black+ program right here.

Bustle’s Charlotte Owen is on a mission to show round Elite Each day:

  • In April, Owen was tapped because the editor-in-chief of the Gen Z-focused publication along with her roles overseeing Bustle and Bustle U.Ok.
  • On the newest episode of the Digiday Podcast, Owen talked about making use of the Bustle method to Elite Each day.

Hearken to the newest Digiday Podcast episode right here.

Publishers consider cost-per-click pricing fashions of their commerce companies:

  • Vice Media Group and Leaf Group’s Hunker are experimenting with the CPC mannequin along with the standard cost-per-acquisition mannequin.
  • A CPC deal sometimes earns publishers between $3,000 and $5,000 per deal monthly.

Learn extra about publishers’ CPC commerce pricing fashions right here.

Media ERGs foster neighborhood amongst hybrid workforces:

  • Publishers’ worker useful resource teams can function the glue holding workers and groups collectively whereas working remotely.
  • ERGs can play an particularly necessary position for brand new and junior workers.

Learn extra about media ERGs right here.

Publishers grapple with youthful audiences avoiding the information:

  • 42% of individuals underneath 35 years previous generally or usually actively keep away from the information.
  • Youthful audiences’ information aversion was a reason behind consternation amongst a panel of executives and editors from The New York Occasions, Vox Media, Reuters and Google Information Lab.

Learn extra about publishers’ youthful viewers issues right here.

What we’re studying

Attack on abortion coverage:
The Nationwide Proper to Life Committee is making an attempt to get states to move legal guidelines that could possibly be used to stop journalists from offering protection that embody details about getting an abortion, similar to New York Magazine’s recent abortion guide (or doubtlessly even this article that hyperlinks to that information), in accordance with Scalawag.

Layoffs at Substack:
The e-newsletter platform supplier has laid off 14% of its workers and has slowed its hiring tempo in an effort to handle the corporate’s prices after canceling its fundraising plan, in accordance with The New York Occasions.

Did the pandemic make publishers recession-proof?:
Media executives really feel just like the strikes their firms made to climate the pandemic have ready them to face up to the looming potential of one other financial recession, in accordance with CNBC.

BuzzFeed’s bumbled SPAC sell-off:
Intelligencer has printed a deep-dive on how BuzzFeed allegedly bumbled its present and former workers’ talents to promote their shares within the firm when the writer went public late final 12 months.

Creators combat misinformation:
Platforms together with YouTube are sometimes cited as founts of misinformation, however some YouTube creators in addition to Twitch streamers have been utilizing the digital video platforms to host debates and dispel conspiracy theories, in accordance with CNET.

Source link

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.